Miami Dolphins Initial Depth Chart Breakdown: Surprises and Storylines

The Miami Dolphins released their first depth chart on Wednesday before their preseason bout against the Bears. For the most part it came pretty much how we expected but it did not come without any surprises. We will dig into those here as we get clarity on the team we will see week one in Indianapolis.

Darren Waller Listed as TE1, Without Practicing

Perhaps the most surprising name at the top of the depth chart is Darren Waller, listed as TE1 despite not logging a single practice rep during camp. Waller, who came out of retirement this offseason, has been held out as the team eases him back in following his year-long absence from football.

Head coach Mike McDaniel said the team is “being smart” about Waller’s workload, suggesting this is a projection of what he can be — not where he is right now. When healthy, Waller’s size, route-running, and red-zone presence offer a massive upgrade to a tight end group that lost such a key contributor in Jonnu Smith.

Behind him, the depth chart is thin. Julian Hill, Pharoah Brown, Tanner Conner, and Hayden Rucci haven’t separated themselves, making Waller’s return to form more than just a luxury — it’s a necessity.

Kendall Sheffield as CB2?

Kendall Sheffield’s rise to the CB2 spot is one of camp’s biggest defensive surprises. After bouncing around several teams in recent years, Sheffield has made the most of his opportunities, consistently flashing in one-on-ones and showing improved technique in zone coverage.

His elevation likely says just as much about Jack Jones, the former Patriot, who many assumed would start opposite of second year standout Storm Duck. But Jones has been inconsistent, and the staff appears to be making him earn the role. With Mike Hilton manning the slot, the Dolphins have an interesting — but unsettled — trio.

It’s a high-risk, high-reward group. Duck is a physical press corner who’s looked sharp early, but the room needs stability — and someone to become the clear CB2 before Week 1.

Ashtyn Davis Starting Over Ifeatu Melifonwu

Another notable defensive shift: Ashtyn Davis appears to be the starter opposite Minkah Fitzpatrick, beating out Ifeatu Melifonwu, Elijah Campbell, and Patrick McMorris. Davis has been one of camp’s quieter risers, showing range, physicality, and improved instincts in both deep zones and run fits.

This is a position group where versatility matters. Fitzpatrick’s ability to cover in the slot, play single-high, or even roll down in the box opens up options — but only if the safety next to him can be trusted in coverage.

The Dolphins’ safeties combined for zero interceptions last season. That can’t happen again if this defense hopes to elevate in 2025.

🧱 WR Spots 3–6: Loaded and Competitive

There’s no mystery at the top: Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle are the starters. But behind them, a full-blown competition is underway.

Nick Westbrook-Ikhine brings size (6’2″, 215) and red-zone ability. Malik Washington, the dynamic rookie out of Virginia, has turned heads with his burst and precise slot work. Both are locks for the roster.

Then there’s a crowded mix competing for the final 1–2 spots: Tahj Washington, Erik Ezukanma, Tarik Black, and Andrew Armstrong.

Miami may keep six receivers, and special teams contributions could be the deciding factor. Keep an eye on snap counts and alignment in Sunday’s game — the staff is watching closely.

Punter Duel: Stonehouse vs. Bailey

The Dolphins’ punting battle between Ryan Stonehouse and Jake Bailey might fly under the radar, but it’s a legitimate one. Stonehouse, known for his booming leg, brings elite hangtime and directional ability. Bailey, the more experienced option, offers consistency and excels in short-field situations.

Both have reportedly been sharp in camp, trading strong performances. The deciding factor may come down to holding for field goals — an underrated but crucial component of special teams.

Looking Ahead:

This Sunday’s preseason game against the Bears should provide a better sense of who’s separating themselves – both for roster spots and potential starting roles. I’ll break down the top things to watch later this week and share updates on projected cuts and risers after the game.

The 2025 Dolphins are taking shape – and while some question marks remain, this version of the team looks to be more dynamic and entertaining than last year’s.