Pressure Point: Enough of Tua, time for Dolphins to see what Quinn Ewers can do
The best that can be said about the Miami Dolphins’ putrid performance in Pittsburgh (try saying that ten times fast) is the fantasy that they were actually in playoff contention can be mercifully flushed.
Monday night, in their most important game of the season, the Dolphins froze up in yet another frigid failure in December.
The 25-18 drubbing administered by the Steelers confirmed the inevitable: Miami’s drought without a playoff win will hit the quarter century mark before the end of the month.
More than that, it showed that in four seasons of Mike McDaniel as coach and six years of Tua Tagovailoa at quarterback, nothing has changed.
No progress. No hope left for this season. Zilch.
Only one thing is left to accomplish in the final three games of this latest of lost seasons. Find out what they have in rookie quarterback Quinn Ewers.
I’ve been patient with Tua because I’ve seen the greatness in him.
I don’t know why he has regressed so badly…no one outside the building does…but this off-season will be critical for him. Either he gets back to playing at a high level, or the #Dolphins need to move on. https://t.co/fUx7MKKFzC
— Chris at Phins.com (@PhinsChris) December 16, 2025
Tagovailoa falls short as franchise quarterback
If he’s not a viable option, the Dolphins will need to start looking elsewhere for their quarterback of the future, asap.
Because it’s not Tagovailoa. He’s not getting better, he’s gotten significantly worse this season.
Asked about giving Ewers an audition now that the Dolphins are eliminated from playoff contention, McDaniel handled the question about as poorly as he did with the game plan against the Steelers.
“Yeah, I think it would be very irrational, shortsighted if I even tried to tackle that option,” he said. “I think I have to look at the tape. I’ll move on from there.”
What he’ll see on the tape is another failure of Tagovailoa to deliver what a franchise quarterback must with the season on the line.
It was a very Tua-like performance, producing a stat line totally misaligned with how he played.
It featured another bad interception — his league-leading 15th — to end an early drive into Steelers territory. Later, when he tried to scramble for a first down that would have kept another drive going, his slide came up short.
I know it’s hard to believe, but the majority of Dolphins fans aren’t Tua “haters” or Tua “stans.” Most of us just want to see our team win football games, and that clearly isn’t happening right now.
When Tua was winning and playing at his best, we had his back and stood by him.…
— The Kevin Harlan Effect (@KevHarlanEffect) December 16, 2025
Tagovailoa outplayed by 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers
In the third quarter, when the game got away from the Dolphins, the Tua-led offense produced minus-20 yards. It was the least productive quarter of McDaniel’s tenure.
Then, after gray-beard Aaron Rodgers led the Steelers on four consecutive touchdown drives for a 28-3 lead, Tagovailoa padded his stats in the fourth quarter against Pittsburgh’s prevent defense.
The pair of late touchdown passes to Darren Waller served only to raise the question, why didn’t they get the big tight end involved when the game was still in question?
Asked what went wrong with the passing game, McDaniel said, “I think passing, a lot of times people squarely put focus on the quarterback. I think there’s several times tonight, one in particular stands out, where I think he was about to make the right read, and we had our [primary receiver] fall over.
“I thought Darren [Waller] made a ton of plays at the end. Should have got him involved earlier. There’s a lot of things. Ultimately it hasn’t been good enough. I think that hurt us tonight.”
Troy Aikman bashing the Dolphins. Join the club, Troy. pic.twitter.com/gIKbEGNCXb
— Will Manso (@WillManso) December 16, 2025
Aikman ridicules Tagovailoa, Dolphins offense
While McDaniel was reluctant to heap blame on Tagovailoa, the CBS announcing crew didn’t hold back. Referring to the interception and other questionable throws, analyst and former quarterback Troy Aikman said, “It’s a little bit of a head scratcher. Those type of throws, you’re not quite sure what he’s seeing or not seeing.”
What we’ve seen all season is a quarterback with very little mobility making poor choices and unable to make a throw with the zip needed to connect downfield.
The interception came on an underthrown ball for Jaylen Waddle that floated like a wobbly duck while Asante Samuel Jr. maneuvered for the pick.
Tua’s pocket presence has also diminished. Typically, he looks once, twice, then finding nobody open and feeling the walls collapsing on him, he starts running around like someone with his hair on fire searching for a blanket to smother it.
He was sacked four times Monday. Yet, Tua’s numbers (22 of 28 for 253 yards and 113.2 passer rating) belie the reality of what transpired in another missed opportunity to break out of the narrative that has haunted this franchise for 25 years.
Tua has 0 mobility, 0 arm strength, and 0 awareness. Can’t believe Dolphins fans still think he’s some demigod savior after 6 years of accomplishing absolutely nothing for them. pic.twitter.com/8l26Q14A04
— Master At Work (@MasterAtWorkinc) December 16, 2025
Dolphins flop again in prime-time chill
Here are the numbers that matter: the Dolphins have lost their past 14 games with the temperature under 40 degrees, including the past six with Tua; they are 4-13 in primetime under McDaniel.
As is often the case, it was more than a defeat, it was a prime-time embarrassment. It had Aikman repeatedly ridiculing the Dolphins’ lack of urgency and overall strategy in the fourth quarter.
It had two former Dolphins contributing to their demise. Defensive back Jalen Ramsey had a rare sack. Tight end Jonnu Smith took a handoff out of the backfield and ran 14 yards untouched for Pittsburgh’s final, in-your-face touchdown.
Realistically, the Dolphins season was sunk by the 1-6 start that was as dismal as the numbers indicated.
Give them credit, they didn’t pack it in at that point. They responded admirably, improved in several parts of their game and played themselves into respectability.
But let’s face it, that surge of five wins in six games was a mirage. The only quality win was the rare rout of the Buffalo Bills at home.
All that’s left of 2025 is to look to the future. That should start with giving Ewers a chance to show if might be a viable alternative. The seventh-round draft pick from Texas made some tantalizing throws in a mop-up opportunity against Cleveland.
Certainly, McDaniel and the offensive coaches have seen a lot more of Ewers from months of practice. But only game action can tell the full story.
I do not understand how Tua Turndaballova is still a starting QB in the NFL pic.twitter.com/O8jwLqsW7R
— Josh Benzo (@JoshBenzo) December 16, 2025
Tagovailoa’s contract straps Dolphins under cap
Unfortunately, the Dolphins are bound to Tua by a contract that has already cost Chris Grier the general manager’s job. Realistically, they are probably stuck with him at least through 2026.
Improvement by the defense and offensive line as the season progressed suggests that the Dolphins don’t need a total roster blowup. There is talent to work with, and the current rookie class has shown promise.
The Dolphins are in a salary cap bind for 2026, due in large part to Tagovailoa’s contract.
But just because they are on the hook to pay him an ungodly amount doesn’t mean they have to play him if there is a better option on the payroll. The final three games can shed light on that possibility.
No doubt most Dolfans have seen enough of Tua for this sorry season.
I’m totally Tua-ed out.
Question is, will McDaniel and the front office have the good sense to pull the switch for the final three games? Will owner Steve Ross demand it?
All we are saying is give Quinn Ewers a chance.
Craig Davis has covered South Florida sports and teams, including the Dolphins, for more than four decades. Follow him on the site formerly known as Twitter @CraigDavisRuns.









