Well, well, well.
The Miami Dolphins’ 30-13 upset of Josh Allen and the Buffalo Bills on Sunday at Hard Rock Stadium was like looking out and spotting a chartreuse unicorn in your backyard.
Seeing Allen frustrated by the Dolphins is something rarely if ever seen before. They went toe-to-toe with their long-time nemesis and prevailed, ending a seven-game skid against their division rival.
They made big plays on offense, led by De’Von Achane’s 225 yards from scrimmage (174 yards rushing) and two touchdowns.
The provided an eye-opening response following a humbling loss to the Ravens, the firing of long-time general manager Chris Grier and the trade of popular linebacker Jaelan Phillips.
Clearly all of that was a wakeup call for the Dolphins, who coach Mike McDaniel described as “quite honestly, a little salty.”
The Miami defense, especially, played pissed off and determined. Which begs the question why that mindset wasn’t more prevalent in many of the lackluster performances earlier in the season.
“It’s pretty obvious from their play they didn’t believe their season was over,” said McDaniel, whose job is in jeopardy due to the team’s ragged play the first half of the season. “They chose to believe, throughout the whole thing … They made that decision to continue to believe and continue to invest in each other.”
Win detrimental to Dolphins’ draft position
The one conclusion that can be drawn is that this team has not quit on its coach.
For Dolphins, now 3-7 amid a disappointing season, it’s something to build on, though it didn’t aid the larger rebuilding task ahead of them, in regards to draft position.
It was a surreal day for the Fins and their fans.
It began with a report by NFL insider Tom Pelissero made the best pitch of any team for Dolphins wide receiver Jaylen Waddle at the trade deadline last week. According to Pelissero, the Bills offered a first-round draft pick in 2027 and a third-rounder in 2026.
The Dolphins reportedly wanted the first-round pick in 2026, so no deal.
That brought mixed reaction from Dolfans, especially those who want the team to tank this season and accumulate as much draft capital for the future as possible.
Building through the draft is the way to go, but I’m not onboard with trading one of their best assets on offense to an opponent in their division that they must find a way to get past in the years ahead.
That was a mistake the franchise made in 2007 when they traded wide receiver Wes Welker to the Patriots for a couple of draft picks. It haunted the Dolphins for years, while Welker contributed significantly to the Patriots dynasty as a favorite target of Tom Brady.
Jaylen Waddle has big game after nearly being traded
Fitting that Waddle reiterated his value to the Dolphins with five receptions for 84 yards, including a spectacular 38-yard grab from Tua Tagovailoa for the game’s first touchdown while being covered so aggressively by Bills rookie Maxwell Hairston drew a flag for interference.
Keep in mind, if they trade Waddle, their best receiver in the absence of injured Tyreek Hill – who may never suit up for Miami again – that becomes a big hole to fill.
In addition, any draft picks that might have been acquired from the Super Bowl-contending Bills figure to be late-round.
While Tagovailoa (two touchdown passes, two interceptions) led the offense to four touchdowns and a field goal, it was the defense that stood out in throttling a dangerous opponent.
Allen, the Bills’ super-star quarterback, has owned them. Often he has humiliated them. He came in 14-2 against Miami.
Dolphins’ defense gives inspired effort
Sunday was altogether different. The Dolphins defense intercepted him in the endzone and forced him to fumble in the fourth quarter while a comeback was still within reach. They sacked him three times and had seven quarterback hits.
They also contained running back James Cook (53 yards, 4.1 per carry).
They played with resolve rarely seen this season, led by Jordyn Brooks, Bradley Chubb, Tyrel Dodson and Mikah Fitzpatrick. Zach Sieler finally got his first sack of the season and Ifeatu Melifonwu his first interception as a Dolphin.
With veteran cornerback Rasul Douglas out with an injury, they got strong play from young cornerbacks including Jack Jones (forced fumble), JuJu Brents (fumble recovery) and Jason Marshall Jr.
This game did nothing to alter the balance of power in the AFC East. It could be viewed as a trap game for the Bills, who were coming off an emotional win over the Kansas City Chiefs, the main obstacle for their Super Bowl ambition.
This reminded me of the “Wildcat game” in 2008 when the lowly Dolphins stunned the Patriots 38-13. The Patriots were on a 21-game regular-season winning streak and 12.5-point favorites. They were surprised by running back Ronnie Brown taking shotgun snaps in a college-style offense.
This one wasn’t built around a gimmick. Instead the Dolphins gave the sort of determined effort, on offense and defense, that they struggled to muster until this season wilted into a lost cause.
Dolphins remain an enigma despite win over Bills
“I’m proud of this team,” Tagovailoa said.
How much of what they exhibited in beating the Bills convincingly is who they really are?
The seven remaining games will provide a more definitive answer. As well as determine whether McDaniel remains as coach beyond this season and how much of the roster is worth retaining as a foundation.
It is said that a team is what its record says it is. By that measure, the Dolphins are a 3-7 team with numerous flaws. It remains to be seen who will be entrusted with improving the roster in the ongoing quest of the first playoff win in a quarter century.
But give them credit, against the Bills they played with the sort of conviction and competence it takes to achieve that objective. For one week, at least, they answered the charge that their coach and quarterback can’t win against playoff-caliber teams.
Even the embarrassed Fins fan with a paper bag over his head had his arms up in celebration.
And for once, Josh Allen was left wearing a frown.
Craig Davis has covered South Florida sports and teams, including the Dolphins, for more than four decades. Follow him on the site formerly known as Twitter @CraigDavisRuns.