Marlins bullpen has gone from strength to weakness
After a 5-3 loss to the San Diego Padres on Sunday, the Miami Marlins made franchise history with their 12th consecutive defeat.
The Marlins quickly went from firmly in the playoff picture to three games out, with five teams — including San Diego — to chase.
The Los Angeles Dodgers suffered an 11-game slide before finishing the 2017 season in the World Series. Miami is only one win from shifting back to a playoff contender hovering over .500.
The biggest problem for the Marlins recently has been their bullpen. Miami has been outscored 24-10 after the seventh inning during their losing streak. Two of their three losses against Milwaukee were walk-offs.
The Marlins were leading 3-1 in the eighth inning until home runs from Manny Machado and Jackson Merrill highlighted a 4-run Padres rally. That’s the issue with overusing the bullpen. While every other reliever went through their innings without a run allowed, it only takes one pitcher to get ambushed by opposing bats and change the game.
It was Lake Bachar on Sunday, but it was Tyler Zuber on Friday, when he gave up a go-ahead two-run homer in a 4-2 loss.
Overall, the bullpen has put up a 5.45 ERA since July 10, which is the fifth highest in baseball.
Fairbanks is solid at home, but when he’s on the mound anywhere but loanDepot park, his ERA jumps up to over 13.00. And this is the closer commanding the most money the Marlins ever spent on a relief pitcher in franchise history.
An argument can be made Fairbanks should’ve been on the mound in the eighth against San Diego’s heavy hitters instead of Bachar. Marlins manager Clayton McCullough indicated after the game he will continue to send out a variety of relievers in high-leverage situations, saying, “who you see pitch in the eighth inning one day might pitch in the sixth inning.”
“I’ve been using Pete in the ninth inning,” McCullough said. “Right now, [going to] continue to do that, and again, like Lake or whoever else we have down there, feel terrific about that. When you talk about [matching up with] parts of the order, but OK, if you get through the eighth, like someone’s going to throw the ninth, too. I think I just have to — and will — remain very confident in the group we have, and you know what? Right now, we’re just not getting it done.”

The Marlins’ bullpen hasn’t been the same since Tyler Phillips went from being their most reliable reliever to a solid starting pitcher. The unit is also suffering injuries in the form of Andrew Nardi and Anthony Bender. They almost lost reliever Michael Petersen (2.84 ERA) too. He left Sunday’s game with a right forearm contusion after being struck by a batted ball, but fortunately the X-rays were negative.
The Marlins will send Phillips (2-5, 3.52 ERA) on the mound against the Philadelphia Phillies on Monday.






Paddack has a 7.63 ERA and 5.00 FIP in 30 ⅔ innings pitched through a season he described as a “roller coaster.”
Left-handed pitcher Robby Snelling (No. 2 prospect) last pitched on Friday against Durham, earning International League Pitcher of the Week honors tossing five no-hit innings with nine strikeouts in Triple-A Jacksonville’s 12-0 win. His next scheduled start lines up with when the Marlins need Paddack’s replacement to go on Friday against the Washington Nationals.
Garrett proved to be a solid pitcher for the Marlins since his MLB debut in 2020. His best season was in 2023, where he recorded a 3.66 ERA with an 8.79 K/9 in 31 outings, as well as starting in Game 2 of the National League Wild Card series against Philadelphia.
“I felt Janson overall was really terrific,” McCullough said on Monday. “Outside of that sweeper to Bryce that probably didn’t catch well and just kind of stayed more middle of the plate that he was able to put a swing on. To go out there and to get us to where he got there and one run, you should win that game.” 
Norby posted a .924 fielding percentage during 30 games at third base in 2024 and improved to .954 through 82 games last year. He said he “worked really hard at third this spring,” knowing that he is competing for a full-time spot with a recipient of a Gold Glove as a utility fielder. He welcomed adding first base to his list of positions because the true goal is to “be in the lineup every day and putting up consistent at-bats and having my bat in the lineup.”
“That’s more so the thing that I’m working through the most and getting as comfortable as I can,” Norby said. “But overall, I feel great.”
With 27 RBI this season, Hicks leads the Marlins in the category and is second in the big leagues, behind only Cincinnati Reds rookie first baseman and Miami native Sal Stewart (29). 
His bat has taken the next step this year, batting .337 with a .945 OPS through 22 games. He was a double shy of a cycle last Friday against the Milwaukee Brewers.
“I did that in years past and it’s kind of put pressure on myself to feel like I need to hit certain numbers,” Edwards said. “My goal this year is to play my game do my best every day and at the end of the year, I’ll look up and be happy with what I got.”
“We had a bit of an older team in 23 and now we’re one of the younger teams in the league,” Edwards said. “We made the playoffs that year and we got a good team this year, so looking to do the same this year. It’s been a lot of turnover but it’s a great group that we have here. It’s been a treat to come to the field with these guys and to suit up with them and spend time in the clubhouse. We got a great group.”